

November 21 - February 27, 2027 | KUBE gallery, Genk (BE)
Tragedy of the Commons is a collection of large and small-scale mixed media paintings by North American artist Shaun Richards (US and Greece) that infers the deference of the general population amidst the ongoing fragmentation of Western socio-economic ideals. The phrase, “Tragedy of the commons” was first coined by Garret Hardin in a 1968 essay whose major concern was overpopulation. In this essay he uses a classical example first discussed by Aristotle in his foundational 4th century BCE work, Politics, which states “That which is common to the greatest number has the least care bestowed upon it.”
Essentially, when individuals use a shared common resource for personal gain, they will deplete or ruin the resource for everyone. Depictions of various forms of play, action, and movement against collaged backgrounds of various media such as arms, ammunition, pro-capitalist propaganda, and illustrations visualize skewed socioeconomic concerns that err towards self-sabotage: lack of gun control and indifference to school shootings, corporate interest over environmental sustainability, the business of war for profit, and increasingly privatized incarceration. Layered yet graphic, these visuals infer that among the many common resources in question are also generations to come.
With an accompanying essay by Dr. Amanda M. Maples.
The inherent logic of the commons remorselessly generates tragedy.
–Garret Hardin 1968: 1244
We suffer more often in imagination than in reality.
–Lucius Annaeus Seneca, Roman philosopher (4 BC to 65 AD)
The term “commons” derives from the Latin root word communis, where com means ‘together’ and munis ‘under obligation’—indicating a shared sense of duty and integrity. During Roman times it tied to the res communis, or things belonging to or enjoyed collectively. More classical examples of ‘the commons’ reach us from medieval Europe, specifically England, where natural resources—fisheries, forests, grazing land—were a shared reserve that benefitted all community members. Yet, when driven by individual self-interest (an unfortunate yet all too ‘common’ human deficiency), the commons can be over-exploited, leading to exhaustion of the resources and ultimately a tragedy of depletion, effecting the collective and complicating the whole damn system—thus necessitating a clear set of rules developed and adhered to by the community to protect what was collectively owned and maintain balance. The metaphor still stands today—most often used in relation to ecological or environmental concerns—and largely due to the phrase “Tragedy of the commons,” first coined by Garret Hardin in a 1968 essay whose major concern was overpopulation. In this essay he uses a classical example first discussed by Aristotle in his foundational 4th century BCE work, Politics, which states: “That which is common to the greatest number has the least care bestowed upon it.” Essentially, when individuals use a shared common resource for personal gain, they will deplete or ruin the resource for everyone. Critics of Hardin’s thesis note its misalignment with common property in the real world, but important political insights on the nature and consequences of capitalism might flip the metaphor on its head: The Tragedy of Privatization, or the privately-owned.
There is an implicit lesson here in the dangers of privatization, but equally in the lack of individual complicity and responsibility.
Today, the idea of the commons and its dis- or misuse is not limited to environmental movements and ecologies, extending to other forms of shared social and intangible capital: culture, the arts, and the digital realm—knowledge commons, digital commons, urban commons, health commons, cultural commons, and so on. In today’s context, where Internet and social media outlets determine the ways in which we connect and understand the world and one another—our social interactions writ large—the digital and cultural commons dominate how we measure, mitigate, and mete out other forms of political, social, and resource capital. Our “commons” have expanded, complicating the access and livability of the common person and shaping a fallacy of desire for the promised “American dream”—what is owed, what is or should be common, and what continues to be physically at a distance, yet present ad nauseum online. (Figs. 1 and 2)

Fig. 1 Adjusted Gross Income, featuring the artist, 2012. Oil and mixed media on canvas, 91 x 152 cm.

Fig. 2 The artist in front of his work The Campaign, on view at the North Carolina Museum of Art, 2012.
This broadened and dissociative version of Hardin’s “tragedy of the commons” sets the stage for a collection of large and small-scale mixed media paintings by North American artist Shaun Richards (US and Greece). Richards’s Tragedy of the Commons brings together works from the artist’s Rhetoric series (2019-2024) with paintings created from 2025-2026 between New Orleans, Louisiana and on residency in Genk, Belgium (May 2025), all of which collectively indicate the deference of the general population amidst the ongoing fragmentation of Western socio-economic ideals. Beyond complacency, Richards forces us to confront our own complicity in a 21st century environment saturated by violence and excess. Depictions of various forms of play, action, and movement are set atop collaged backgrounds of assorted print media, such as arms and ammunition catalogues and pro-capitalist propaganda/publications, visualizing skewed socioeconomic concerns that err towards self-sabotage: lack of gun control and indifference to school shootings, corporate interests over environmental sustainability, the business of war for profit amidst increasingly privatized incarceration, and the willingness to sacrifice distanced or unknown neighbors for the sake of comfort and decadence. Our fingers swipe past visuals of global trauma and “health” & beauty advertisements in equal parts, losing our individuality and empathy to late night doom scrolling. Graphically layered, Richards’s visuals of painterly tenderness and depth atop casual two-dimensional capitalist pulp force us to remember the casualties—children in many cases--inferring that among the many common resources in question are also generations to come. When flipped on its head yet again, “tragedy of the commons” becomes “tragedies of the common.”

Rhetoric (slide), 2021. Oil, acrylic, collage and silver leaf on canvas, 182 x 182 cm.
In many ways, the theme of Tragedy of the Commons carries forward a thread already present in Richards’s oeuvre over the last 20 years, beginning with his 2006 Women and Children First at Flanders Gallery (Raleigh, NC) that reacted to the oversexualization of girls and young women in popular culture from the 1950s into the 1990s and leading to unrealistic body images that instead feed fantasies of male desire. This was followed by a 2010 solo exhibition titled Crash that featured life-size paintings of car crashes set atop landscapes created from his characteristic and cautionary mixture of print media (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3 Shaun Richards’s Crash series at the Bemis Center for Contemporary Art, Omaha, NE. 2010.
Painted at the time of a major stock market crash in the United States, it called attention to and criticized the use of taxpayer dollars to bail out the bank and auto industries deemed “too big to fail.” The crumpled metal autos echo the ripple effect such a crash would have on the working class but equally the “rubber-necking” all too common to traffic disasters: passing slowly by and doing nothing to assist yet compromising progress. This show was followed closely by Concession Stand in 2011 (Fig. 4)—coinciding with the explosion of social media and an incessant pressure to constantly post and share—to be seen, quantified, judged, consumed.

Fig 4 Concession Stand at Flanders Gallery, Raleigh, NC. 2011.
Concession Stand presented a grid of painted advertising, like Busch Beer’s “It doesn’t get any better than this” superimposed with a giant skull created out of beer caps (Fig. 5), or IOU that featured Frank McNamara, the inventor of the first credit card (Diner’s Club, 1950), regurgitating paint—a nod that extends to the artist personally who is himself a target, yet questioned his own drive to post (advertise) in order to sell. Standard Deviation (2014) too featured “disaster aesthetics”—its central work depicting a gray silhouette of a man on the back of a rearing horse, a woman on her knees with a destroyed home and a field of debris, and the word “STANDARD” lingering in the background.

Fig. 5 Shimmer Skull from the Concession Stand series, 2011. Wood, acrylic, collage, and bottle caps on panel, 244 x 244 cm.
Other works leading up to the present Tragedy of the Commons were featured at the Contemporary Art Museum in Raleigh in 2021. Some of this show revisited the theme of Women and Children First (see Fig. 6) while the rest responded to the social and political events of 2019-2020—the murder of George Floyd and other unarmed Black citizens by police; a global pandemic; the #metoo and Black Lives Matters movements, which saw parallel elsewhere in the globe; and mass shootings which have continued to take place in the United States, particularly at schools. The mass shootings are easily read in Richards’s iconography of empty chairs and playground equipment, yet the children contorting their bodies in active but unnatural ways is achingly and hauntingly beautiful. The battered basketball hoop feels listless and underused, while the slide’s surface gleaming in silver leaf echoes a cleanliness and purity that is sullied by the pages of vintage gun catalogues that serve as its landscape. In an interview about the series (November 2026), Richards muses: “Why is gun violence so prevalent in the US, while other countries remain immune in comparison? Why do these unrestrained laws remain in effect and unchanged?” Perhaps it stems from the origins of the 2nd Amendment and the right to bear arms, which in theory grew out of English common law and a distrust of standing armies during the American colonial period, but which some scholars claim actually ties to state-run militias and the fear of insurrection by enslaved individuals who of course were banned from owning or carrying arms. It is worth pondering how this has played into America’s current racialized police state.
Americans still cling to such laws, fearing that by giving an inch, they’d lose “the mile” and largely refusing to vote for legislation that would keep access to guns in check. Instead, an internal arms race rages despite the need to protect our children, and the contemporary public has inherited a racialized system that still derives economic and social value through the exploitation of minorities. And yet—how much longer are the marginalized the 'minority’? Aren’t they now the American majority? The “common”?
“How, then, do you describe and challenge societal self-sabotage?” Richards asks.

Fig. 6 Revisionist Histories, 2019. Oil on canvas, 91 x 76 cm.
The largest and most ambitious of the series acts as a response. The work is titled Caucus, but the artist informally, and with a bit of truthful tongue-in-cheek, calls it “White Privilege on the Move.” Caucus is the culmination of a new process begun for the Rhetoric series, and the artist’s effort to capture and visualize this political and conceptual ground through media. Initially Richards aimed to create the gun catalogue background with more opacity so that the pages were only occasionally visible behind the children and playground ephemera—a marriage of two opposites. Yet he was struck by the pattern it created, and this holds true especially for Caucus.
The top register creates a lighter sky-like effect and is ‘constituted’ from pages of the American Constitution itself, whereas the bottom ground upon which the young, white, and apathetic “suit-and-ties” tread is sourced from the 1957 novel Doctor Zhivago by Russian poet Boris Pasternak. The opposites here are clear: a communist, socialist revolution that failed miserably vs American Capitalism and the assumption of racial and national superiority. The Constitution is held in high esteem and hovers above a demonized “Communism,” which is today conflated with socialist policies in America—where Socialist Democrats like Bernie Sanders are assumed and feared to be the first step towards communism or fascism.

Causus, 2021. Oil, acrylic and collage on canvas, 182 x 264 cm.
However, the middle ground between the two is a derelict strip mall. Though malls flourished in the 1980s and became the dominant cultural ‘third space’ for youth into the ‘90s, their structural oversupply ultimately led to their collapse, echoing the failures of the American government to serve its working classes amidst 1980s Reaganomics and tax incentives that benefitted Wall Street and corporate interests. The mirror here, for Richards, is that a capitalist golden age of limitless consumer expansion may not be as bad as communist-era Soviet Union, but it also isn’t much better when looked at from the perspective of the common person. In Caucus, the young male elite stride passively—anesthetized to the surroundings—towards a bright and ‘deserved’ future built on the backs of the unseen masses. The irony is that social-leaning policies, which like gun control laws are already in existence in nearly every other economically advanced country in the world, would largely benefit the common individual. The most precarious—i.e. the lowest classes—are voting against their own best interests and in no small way because of the influence of popular news outlets and social media.
The narrative of the larger works continues in a collection of approximately sixty small and medium-scale pieces on mylar collectively titled Syndication, a word which the artist defines as “selling or distributing the same material to multiple groups or outlets at the same time,” and covering such things as media and the artis, but also loans and other investments. Regarding the collective of works, he continues that his “thinking is about types of imagery, composition, and meaning as suggesting relevance or relationships the same way people sample music, or like still images from a film that together compose a moving picture. The order, pacing, structure—how things are grouped and the spaces between them—pauses to tell the story” (Interview with the author, November 2026). This conglomerate is not dissimilar from the basic elements of an artwork: color, tone, contrast, composition, and so on as well as the common tropes of the art world with which the artist himself must grapple: portraiture, figuration, abstract expressionism, minimalism, graphic arts and illustrations. But, as he stated: “There can be a comfort in banality.” He nods in a way, then, towards graphic or serial arts akin to pop art or band posters. When viewing iconography such as that populating Syndication—airplanes, snakes, a choir girl, stacks of newspapers, slingshots, skulls, mountains, and vultures—one feels a nostalgia in the recognition of the everyday and the vintage, but there are hints of branding as well and the capitalist system at its core. Brand recognition is comforting, but absolute trust in a brand can make for lazy or apathetic consumers.



Syndication collection, Oil, acrylic, collage, graphite and metal leaf on paper. Dimensions variable.
It is no accident that in the context of Tragedy of the Commons, Richards warns that such complacency can translate to capitulation of a governmental order that benefits the few, and a capitalist wolf that markets safety and comfort in exchange for true democratic freedom. Holistically, the series thus continues with the aforementioned emblematic themes he began with in 2006, because for the artist and most of us in the United States, nothing has changed. Throughout the last twenty years and culminating with Tragedy of the Commons, Richards has revealed the world in painfully honest ways, but with a bittersweet and playful nostalgia that makes the medicine go down more easily. But hopefully, not too easily.
Text by Dr. Amanda M. Maples
“Tragedy of the Commons” or Tragedies of the Common?: The Art of Shaun Richards
Kube Gallery, Genk, Belgium, November 21, 2026-February 27, 2027



